The Ishikawa diagram

Ishikawa diagram
The Ishikawa diagram 6

The Ishikawa diagram: an essential tool for Lean Production

The Ishikawa diagram, also known as a fishbone diagram or cause-and-effect diagram, is a tool of fundamental importance in Lean Production. Designed by Japanese engineer Kaoru Ishikawa, this visual tool is widely used to analyse problems and identify their root causes, thus enabling effective corrective actions to be implemented.

Kaoru Ishikawa

What is an Ishikawa diagram and how does it work?

fishbone diagram
The Ishikawa diagram 7

Let's see how to construct an Ishikawa diagram:

1. Define the problem: begin by clearly identifying the problem you wish to analyse.

2. Drawing the backbone: draw a horizontal line and write the problem at the end of the line.

3. Identify the categories of causes: choose the most appropriate categories based on your context.

4. Start brainstorming and generate causes: for each category, brainstorming is initiated with the team to identify all possible causes.

5. Connect the causes: connect the causes to the backbone, creating a tree structure.

6. Analyse the diagram: the primary and secondary causes are identified.

The advantages of using Ishikawa diagrams in Lean Production

1. Clear and immediate display: the graphic representation of the Ishikawa diagram makes complex cause-and-effect relationships easy to understand, even for non-experts.

2. Encouraging collaboration: Creating an Ishikawa diagram requires team involvement, encouraging brainstorming and the sharing of different perspectives.

3. Identification of root causes: going beyond the obvious symptoms, the Ishikawa diagram allows you to dig deeper and discover the real reasons behind a problem.

4. Prioritisation of actionsOnce the main causes have been identified, it is possible to focus on the actions that will have the greatest impact.

5. Continuous improvement: the use of Ishikawa diagrams becomes a habit within the organisation, promoting a culture of continuous improvement.

6. Waste reductionBy identifying and eliminating the root causes of problems, you can help reduce waste and optimise processes.

7. Improved quality: by improving understanding of processes and their interactions, we increase our ability to prevent defects and ensure the quality of products or services.

The categories of causes: the 6Ms (or 5Ms)

Traditionally, the Ishikawa diagram uses the following categories of causes:

  1. Manpower (people): human error, insufficient training, motivation.
  2. Machine: breakdowns, wear and tear, inadequate maintenance.
  3. Material: defects, poor quality, unreliable suppliers.
  4. Method: inefficient procedures, lack of standardisation
  5. Measurement: inaccurate measuring instruments, lack of checks.
  6. Mother Nature (environment) adverse environmental conditions, seasonal variations. The category “Mother Nature”, otherwise known as “Environment”, is often added to consider external factors that may influence the process.

The 5 Whys technique: a deeper dive

5 Why?
The Ishikawa diagram 8

The causes identified during the brainstorming session will be linked to each of the 6Ms, and each of these will bring to light further sub-causes, which should always be explored in depth using the 5 Whys technique.

As the name suggests, the 5 Whys technique involves repeatedly asking the question “Why?” at least five times, starting with the observed effect and digging deeper and deeper into the underlying causes.

How does it work?
Definition of the problem: start by clearly identifying the problem you want to analyse.
For example: “The machine stops frequently.”

1st Because: Why does the machine stop frequently? (Answer: Due to overheating).

2nd Because: Why does the machine overheat? (Answer: Due to a malfunction in the cooling system).

3rd WhyWhy is the cooling system not functioning correctly? (Answer: Due to a faulty sensor).

4th Because: Why is the sensor faulty? (Answer: Due to excessive vibrations caused by incorrect belt alignment)

5th Because: Why is the belt alignment incorrect? (Answer: Due to inadequate maintenance.

Key points to remember:
Do not stop at the first level: Often, the first cause identified is not the deepest one. It is important to keep digging until you reach the root of the problem.
Be specific: Questions should be precise and aimed at identifying the exact cause.
Involve a team: The 5 Whys technique works best when used in a group, as different people can offer different perspectives.
Flexibility: The number of “whys” is not fixed. Sometimes fewer than five may suffice, while other times more may be needed. The goal is always to get to the root cause.
Corrective action: Once the root cause has been identified, it is essential to implement corrective actions to eliminate it permanently.
Why it works:
Simplicity: It is an easy technique to understand and apply.
Effectiveness: It allows you to identify the root causes of problems, even the most hidden ones.
Flexibility: It can be applied to any type of problem, in any sector.
Encourage critical thinking: Encourage people to reflect on the causes of problems and find creative solutions.
The 5 Whys technique, combined with the Ishikawa diagram, is a powerful tool for analysing problems and improving processes.
By applying it systematically, companies can identify the root causes of problems, implement effective corrective actions, and achieve continuous improvement.

5 Why?

The Ishikawa diagram and other Lean Production techniques

The Ishikawa diagram integrates perfectly with other Lean Production techniques, such as 5S, the Kanban and the Kaizen. For example, it can be used to identify the root causes of a disorder problem (5S), to optimise material flow (Kanban) or to identify areas for continuous improvement (Kaizen). The Ishikawa diagram is a versatile and powerful tool that can be applied in any business context. Its ability to visualise cause-and-effect relationships and stimulate group collaboration makes it an indispensable tool for improving quality, reducing costs and increasing customer satisfaction.

Sign up to follow upcoming articles

Request Information

Ask for information
Privacy Policy